Episode 168 – UJ in the UK with Rupert Skilbeck

Rupert Skilbeck at the Redress offices in London

In the latest of our long running series of what’s happening with Universal Jurisdictions cases – which is where international crimes tried at a national level outside of the countries they were committed – we turn to the United Kingdom.

Frankly the UK’s record is piss poor! At the heart of this is a unit of the metropolitan police called SO15. Only a handful of successful cases so far. Of course that also shows a robust defence system and gloriously pernickety judges, as it should be. But the rules are complex and have clear gaps, and there don’t seem to have been a huge number of investigations or much appetite when it came to some of the trickier political issues like British troops in Iraq and the Troubles in northern Ireland, and the suppression of the Mau Mau rebellion in Kenya by colonial authorities.

To find out why, Janet set down with Redress Director Rupert Skilbeck in their London office.

For background reading check out The Standing Group on Atrocity Crimes, and their latest report launched at the Inns of court featured below. And the Redress report on what’s needed to fix some aspects of Universal Jurisdiction and the risks of the UK becoming a safe haven.

For lighter reading Rupert suggests A People’s History of the European Court of Human Rights by Michael Goldhaber – 20 years old and a classic of the journalist telling the stories behind a court genre.

And do check out The Hague Justice Week, coming soon! Here’s our livepod.

This podcast has been produced as part of a partnership with JusticeInfo.net, an independent website in French and English covering justice initiatives in countries dealing with serious violence. It is a media outlet of Fondation Hirondelle, based in Lausanne, Switzerland.

read a transcript of this episode

Disclaimer: Asymmetrical Haircuts is produced as a podcast, meaning it is meant to be listened to and not read. Because of this, we recommend that you listen to the episode while reading, because the written word does not do justice to the emotion or tone used by our speakers. However, because we recognise there might be bandwidth issues or you might be using a hearing aid, we have provided written transcripts for all our available episodes.

Rupert Skilbeck: 00:00  Blocks are put up, money is not allocated, people are moved to other jobs. I can imagine the advice given that the minister said, well, I’m thinking that we should prosecute these 10 people responsible for crime. Well, that would be very brave, minister, were you to do that. 

[INTRO MUSIC]

Narrator: 00:14  Our society is completely broken. This argument of self-defence, it died a long time ago. We have lunatics and crazies involved in the ICC. Trials are not conducted by the court of public opinion. You’re listening to Asymmetrical Haircuts, the international justice podcast with Janet Anderson and Stephanie Van Den Berg. This episode was produced in partnership with justiceinfo.net. All rise.

Stephanie: 00:40  Hi, Janet.

Janet: 00:41  Hi, Steph.

Stephanie: 00:42  I’ve been seeing a lot of stuff on social media. So what are you getting us into now?

Janet: 00:48  Oh, I’m sorry. But yeah, I’ve agreed that we’re going to do a live podcast and that’s coming up soon.

Stephanie: 00:56  Yeah. Give us more details. Our listeners want to know when, where, what?

Janet: 01:02  Okay. It’s on November 17th and it’s going to be in front of a live audience in The Hague. We’ve done this a couple of times, haven’t we? It’s going to be at Leiden University at Vine Harbour. That’s here in The Hague. It’s at 16:00 Hague time.

Stephanie: 01:16  And what are we going to be talking about specifically? Because there is confusion about this, at least for me, because I’ve been working so hard that I haven’t been paying attention. 

Janet: 01:26  Well, it’s all about the truth. 

Stephanie: 01:28  Ah.

Janet: 01:28  That’s what we’re discussing.

Stephanie: 01:29  As a journalist, that is, of course, my only goal. 

Janet: 01:32  It’s about the truth in relation to these processes that we cover. So the ownership of the truth, the right to the truth, what kind of role that courts and tribunals and so on play in developing the truth, especially what happens to the evidence collected and the stuff that’s used for trials, what role it plays and what specifically civil society worldwide would like that to happen to that kind of evidence, you know, the archival material. And that’s very much to do with what happens here in The Hague, but what happens in other places as well.

Stephanie: 02:09  And so you didn’t just come up with this organically. It’s part of a whole series of events, right? 

Janet: 02:16  Yeah, it is part of The Hague Justice Week. And I definitely didn’t come up with it organically. The co-organisers are Carolyn Edgerton and Rafael Braga da Silva, and they are the ones who’ve really been providing the intellectual heft to make this all happen. Yeah, the bigger picture is a whole week of stuff going on, and we’re just squeezing into it. You can sign up at Eventbrite. We’ll keep you on sharing that link that link to people. Please try to make it to this one, because this one’s going to be fun, in comparison maybe with some of the, the heavier discussions that you might be able to take part in. And you’ll be part of a live audience. 

Stephanie: 02:58  Yeah, we promise to be nice to our audience, and we promise to let you ask questions. And you can also tell us about other stuff. But we’re mostly going to be talking about truth and how tribunals shape truth and what happens to evidence and what happens to and how victims and survivors can play roles in that. But this week, something else.

Janet: 03:20  Ah, well, this week, remember we’re doing a whole long series, sort of month by month, about universal jurisdiction and how it plays out in different places. I went back to my home country, the United Kingdom, a couple of weeks ago, and decided to try to track down somebody to talk about universal jurisdiction, British style.

Stephanie: 03:41  Ooh, I don’t hear very much about universal jurisdiction, British style. Is that because there are very few cases? 

Janet: 03:48  Yeah, so via Rupert Skilbeck, he’s the director of Redress. We kind of delved into why that is. A key word from him is inertia, institutional inertia. And because he’s been on this subject for many, many years, he can really track what has been changing, kind of give a bit of credit where it’s due, but also what hasn’t changed. The bigger picture is also there are loads of restrictions in the UK. It is different from other places. There’s a residency requirement, for example.

Stephanie: 04:21  That’s then slightly different than what it is in the Netherlands, right? So in the Netherlands, you have to be in the country, but you don’t have to be a formal resident. And is that then one of the differences, where in the UK, you have to be a legal resident for them to be able to do a case?

Janet: 04:36  I go into it in detail, and I hesitate as a non-lawyer to be able to express precisely how it is, but it is definitely caused a lot of blocks and arguments before judges as to the degree to which someone is resident or not. Do you remember we did a podcast before with the people who are setting up a thing called the Atrocity Crimes Standing Group? I also went to their launch of their report. That was in one of those, oh God, amazing old inns of courts, you know, fountains, greenery, honey-coloured stones, 1600s buildings, and so on. So it’s really like, you know, it felt like heart of the beast stuff. And this element, okay, we’re only doing universal jurisdiction here, but there’s this bigger picture again of is the UK, kind of, really joined up on all of this stuff? And they were arguing again a lot about that bigger picture on genocide prevention.

Stephanie: 05:38  Yeah, I can see how that would play into a lot of those universal jurisdiction issues as well. And it’s interesting to see how that keeps kind of changing and how from years and years ago, let’s have this one court that does it all in The Hague, shift things back to we have to do it locally as well, because for a myriad of reasons that we go into our podcast many, many times, that court is not quite delivering in the way that people think it is. You see this kind of change of what we see in The Hague and this universal jurisdiction. So I think it’s very timely that this is your series. So thank you so much for delving into these things. 

Janet: 06:21  Well, I mean, you might say the court in The Hague isn’t always delivering. I mean, in the UK, reading the report so far, there have only been three successful cases coming out of the work from this group called SO15, who are the war crimes investigative group of the Metropolitan Police. So there’s a, there’s a lot to delve into of why it’s not working very fast. 

Stephanie: 06:45  OK, so let’s hear from you and Rupert to figure out why that is happening. 

[MUSIC]

Janet: 06:53  So I was reading some background documents about this, and it all gave me a very ‘Thunderbirds is go’ feel because of acronyms like SO15 doing counterterrorism, but also war crimes and things. Can you sort of paint a picture of who’s doing what? What’s SO15?

Rupert Skilbeck: 07:12  So within the Metropolitan Police, Scotland Yard, as they’re traditionally known, there’s a specialist unit, which is the Counterterrorism Command. And they’ve had various acronyms for years. I’m not quite sure why, but the unit that historically has dealt with complex crimes, international crimes and counterterrorism was SO15. I’m not even sure what it stands for. But I think recently they’ve tried to say that they’re no longer called SO15. 

Janet: 07:37  What are they called now? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 07:38  Well, I think they are the war crimes cell within CTC but reality-

Janet: 07:43  CTC being Counterterrorism Command. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 07:46  But everyone refers to them as SO15, as it’s a very nice and easy to remember acronym. So it’s good. 

Janet: 07:52  Okay. Do they have their own money? Do they have a lot of staff? Are they drowning with too many things going on? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 08:00  Yes. So remember this, that this is just the police. So they are the separate investigative part of it. Then you have a series of specialist lawyers within the Crown Prosecution Service who have a team that will focus on these cases as and when they arise. So the police have set up this unit that has a ring-fenced budget. It’s a fairly large unit compared with others around the world. One of the problems they’ve had in the past is that the unit was also responsible for counterterrorism. And so on occasion-

Janet: 08:28  That would be the bigger focus, would it not? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 08:30  Absolutely, so when we had a few years ago the London Bridge attacks, all of the police who were working on investigating international crimes were suddenly moved to investigate that and had to stop work on the international crimes cases. Now we wrote to them and asked them about that and then they changed their mind and put the police back onto it. And what’s happened now is they’ve managed to allocate them permanently to just work on international crimes. But one thing, for example, more recently, that unit is also responsible for espionage prosecutions.

Janet: 08:58  And that’s a big thing in London as well. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 09:00  Exactly, so suddenly in the last couple of years-

Janet: 09:01  The Chinese, the Russians, everybody’s listening in. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 09:03  There’s been lots of prosecutions and cases being brought against people and the success of prosecutions. So some of the police that are investigating war crimes suddenly may get dragged into espionage. So it is a slightly complex area because there are competing demands on their time but they have been seeking as much as possible to secure their staff allocations so they can do the job as they wish to do so.

Janet: 09:24  Are they getting a lot of information in? Is, does that come from the public? Does it come from NGOs like yours? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 09:31  So another thing that the police have done for about 15, 20 years is they do something that used to be called the Community Information Panel and that was set up by the then Director of Public Prosecutions, Keir Starmer. And of course he had a background as a human rights lawyer before he became DPP and before he became the Prime Minister. And so he set up the Community Involvement Panel that was designed to share information on these international crimes between the police and civil society. And so those meetings have gone on for about 15 years, I think, where the police will talk to NGOs, some of them are single country NGOs, some of them are international NGOs doing universal jurisdiction cases, and share information as best they can that can be in the public domain on what cases they’re looking at, whether they need help finding a witness in X country, whether they need an interpreter who can talk about this, whether they need a background expert who knows about the war in Sudan or whatever it might be.

Rupert Skilbeck: 10:24  So that engagement with civil society has been quite useful. And in fact, our colleagues at Trial International have just published a report all about how NGOs engage with war crimes prosecution units around the world. And that format still exists. And so the police still engage twice a year with civil society. There’s also something that is called the War Crimes Prostitution Network. And that brings together all the different bits of the British government who are involved in war crimes prosecutions. So it involves Crown Prosecution Service, the police, it has people from the Home Office, Refugee Unit, who sometimes get people who come in, claim refugee status and at the same time admit that they were participating in international crimes, about 100 people a year do that. They’re involved in it. The Foreign Office is there because they deal with neutral legal assistance requests in the formal way through the central authority that shares information with other countries. And then the Ministry of Defence is there and other departments. And that happens twice a year as well. Again, some NGOs are able to participate in that as observers and participate in those conversations. There’s a lot of engagement with civil society in London as to how these cases are going forward. 

Janet: 11:27  The ICC receives an enormous number of submissions, obviously, it’s kind of like the pinnacle of this mountain of stuff that gets sent in. Is that also happening here? More and more information just gets shoved over to them and said, now it’s over to you. Do they get a lot of referrals? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 11:45  I think there’s some of that. So through this interaction that they have, a lot of NGOs will provide detailed submissions, the same as they might provide an Article 15 submission to the ICC. They will submit a similar dossier of evidence together with a legal analysis that says why crimes are taking place. And various NGOs have done that periodically to bring to the attention of the police, X, Y, Z seems to be present in the UK or is intended to be here shortly. Here’s the information you need. Here’s the legal analysis that you need. I think they also get a lot of people just writing in because they have a very open email address, please write to us. And so a lot of those may just be very thin reports without too much detail. More recently for Ukraine, they put up posters at Heathrow Airport and the Eurostar Terminal calling for people who may have been witnesses to anything that took place to get in contact with them. Now, I think that probably produced an awful lot of information, not much of which was probably very useful because the fact that people may have witnessed-

Janet: 12:38  Because they actually want people in the hierarchy. They don’t need people who’ve just been bombed out of their houses necessarily. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 12:43  Sadly, though. I mean, evidence of the base crimes does have to be proved, obviously, but that’s not the most effective way to prove it. And so I think they ended up probably with more information than they needed for, for that sort of approach. But essentially, they have opened up a large number of ways that you can get in contact with them. But I think the best way is NGOs making more detailed submissions and sending it through to them and often asking for conversations. So the police are very willing to talk to NGOs to talk to them about what they would need and the sort of information they need and what they don’t need. And in particular-

Janet: 13:14  What do they need and what don’t they need, in your experience? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 13:16  Well, one of the issues that comes up in all of these cases, it’s come up with the International Criminal Court, is whether or not you take witness statements and submit them to a criminal standard. And this was a problem. In the, in one of the cases, there’s only been four or five cases in Britain in the last 40 years on war crimes. And one of them was the Kumar Lama case, which was a Nepali person who was accused of atrocities. And in that case, it turned out during the course of the trial that a number of NGOs had taken witness statements from one of the witnesses in the case previously. And those witness statements hadn’t been disclosed and the defence didn’t know about them. And that came out during the course of the trial. And essentially, you ended up with mistrial because the defence are entitled to see previous statements to see if they’re consistent or not. And the risk is if too many statements are taken, if you ask someone-

Janet: 14:03  There’s going to be inconsistency in the end. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 14:06  And a good prosecutor will work out, will explain those inconsistencies or facilitate the witness to do that. But it’s still best not to have that. So the police here, particularly, I think it’s a feature of the common law system a little bit more to be discussed, but the police are very keen that they are the ones who take witness statements. They don’t really want people to produce a perfectly worded witness statement. They prefer to do the work themselves. In the United States, they’ve got this concept of the will say statement, which isn’t a full witness statement, but it’s essentially-

Janet: 14:34  The details that you should expect them to come-

Rupert Skilbeck: 14:36  Exactly. That if you interview this person, they’re likely to tell you about this incident that took place on this day. They’re going to be able to tell you that they saw this person and leave it at that. And then you allow the professional police investigators to go in and do the detailed statements that they can do it in a way that they know is the most effective way in the legal system. So I think that’s one of the conundrums they have. What they do like, same as the International Criminal Court, is really good background information on the context and the conflict. 

Janet: 15:02  Because they don’t have that resource themselves. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 15:04  Absolutely. So you can speed up the process massively if you give any investigator, whether it’s the ICC or a police investigator anywhere in Europe, a detailed summary of the conflict, what’s going on, a summary of the command structures to tell them who is in charge, at what point and how it works. Sometimes they need helpful things like an analysis of the insignia of people involved in the conflict so they can recognise them if that’s the issue. But some of that information that almost certainly NGOs will have access to because they’ll know the experts, they’ll know the witnesses, they’ll know their professors and the academics who’ve looked into this sort of thing. That is really useful information for the police to take forward and they can speed up their investigation significantly doing that. None of it is really admissible evidence. They would need to call an expert witness to prove that, but it means that they sped the process up no end.

Janet: 15:50  I have read that this unit or cell does do structural investigations and I’d had in my mind that, you know, structural investigations are really the most important thing that could ever happen. Look at Germany, that’s why we’ve ended up with so many Syria cases there etc because they went that extra mile to start structural investigations. With so few prosecutions in the UK, I’ve read that there are structural investigations. What’s going on there?

Rupert Skilbeck: 16:24  Well, so this was a problem in the system and we wrote a report two or three years ago, the Clooney Foundation for Justice looking at what needs to be reformed in the system of prosecutions in the UK or in England and Wales and this was one of them, that there was no structural investigations. What that meant was the police would only start investigating when someone was in the country or was imminently about to arrive in the country. That’s hopeless because one of the points-

Janet: 16:48  They can’t get the evidence. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 16:49  Well, they can’t and they need to have the evidence very quickly because under the custody time limits rules in this country, when you arrest someone, you have to either charge them or release them within a fixed period of time, 96 hours. You can get a bit of an extension and so you need to be ready to go. Well, you can’t possibly be ready to go to charge someone with crimes against humanity that quickly and in civil law systems, you don’t have that. The investigating judge will get maybe several years in the Sonko case in Switzerland. I think he had three or four years to do the investigation while the individual was in pre-trial detention while that investigation took place. 

Janet: 17:21  Which is a problem in itself maybe because that may be too long for some of the victims and the vipers but that’s just such a contrast with what? 96 hours. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 17:31  It’s hopeless. So what we had suggested was that they should be able to do structural investigations taking the concept from the ICC where you investigate a situation before you have a suspect, on the understanding you’re likely to get suspects and so actually as it happened, the police essentially just started doing structural investigations.

Janet: 17:48  Why? When did they start them? Why didn’t they start them? How many have they been doing? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 17:52  Certainly when they started their position was that they had opened 17 structural investigations to mirror the 17 situations at the International Criminal Court. And so their position was-

Janet: 18:02  Oh, because that was already happening in The Hague that they should be prepared to do something similar. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 18:09  So they were most likely to get cases relating to ICC investigations. That was the initial position. I think the reality is 17 is an awful lot with a not massive team. And so I think those have now shrunk to much more realistic amounts. 

Janet: 18:21  Yeah, I’ve read recently four, but I don’t know which four they would be. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 18:25  No, I mean, I don’t know off the top of my head, but I’m sure Ukraine is one of them. I suspect Sudan might be one of them. I suspect Rwanda is one of them. And then I don’t know what fourth contender would be-

Janet: 18:34  Could be Syria 

Rupert Skilbeck: 18:35  It could be, yes, it probably is. But that is a change because it means that the police can allocate resources to investigate international crime situations on a preliminary basis without actual suspects. And that means they’re a bit ready to respond as and when suspects might arrive or something like that.

Janet: 18:50  So we’ve mentioned a few different places there. Should we sort of run through what we know a bit on any of those? Probably the one that has been before I sat down this afternoon, the one that was immediate on the top of my brain was Rwanda, because that’s a name that has emerged after it felt like an enormous amount of time that the Brits were sitting on allegations before they’ve actually gone now to arrest somebody. Can you run through that case for us? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 19:20  Yeah, so this case has been going on for I think more than 15 years. So it turned out that there were, at the time, I think it was six suspected genocidaire resident in the United Kingdom. And through various investigations that involved NGOs, including Redress, that was brought to the attention of the authorities. The government of Rwanda then sought to extradite them to be tried for genocide in Rwanda. And then you had a very lengthy hearing at the High Court in London about whether or not the sixth defendant would receive a fair trial in Rwanda. And it was hotly disputed. Experts on both sides gave their views on whether you get a fair trial in Rwanda. The conclusion of the British judges was no, they would not get a fair trial, because the right to a fair trial in these kinds of cases wouldn’t be sufficiently respected when you broke it down. And so you then had a rather-

Janet: 20:04  Which is a fairly dramatic thing to say, considering various places in Europe have transferred people back. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 20:10  Yeah, exactly. Now, I mean, part of it was on the individual circumstances of these individual cases. It wasn’t a decision that would necessarily apply everywhere else. But you’re quite right. Other countries decided that they could be extradited. 

Janet: 20:22  Sufficient safeguards in place. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 20:24  Yes.

Janet: 20:25  No death penalty, that kind of thing. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 20:26  That was put in place. One of the differences is with the British extradition system is that it’s a very adversarial court hearing that takes place over many, many weeks. Whereas in other countries, for example, Belgium, it’s an entirely paper-based system. So an extradition request is decided by a judge on the papers. No oral hearings, no expert evidence. This took weeks in the High Court. And I think it had to be argued twice for some reason, I think in the Court of Appeal as well. And yes, there were certainly experts who were saying, no, you can get a fair trial in Rwanda. It may not be as perfect as you might get in England and Wales, but it certainly meets international standards unless you, you’re prepared to say that no one in Africa can get a fair trial. But when it was broken down, the judge had to find that they wouldn’t get a fair trial. But the test is quite a high one. So anyway, they ended up not being extradited and being in limbo in the United Kingdom, with the government of Rwanda quite aggressively telling the British government, you have to do something with these men, either extradite them or prosecute them. That’s the obligation under international law, extradite or prosecute. And so then a decision was made to move to prosecutions about seven years ago. And the Metropolitan Police had taken, I think, about five or six years to do a detailed investigation that has involved many, many trips to Rwanda to take evidence directly from witnesses. And then earlier last month, they charged one man. I’m not sure where we are with the others, but so far one person has been charged with offences relating to genocide. And that has gone through to a preliminary hearing that will be, I think, due to take place in the Central Criminal Court imminently. And we’ll see where that goes in terms of trial. But I think given the length of time that that investigation has taken, the prosecution will be pretty ready to take it for trial. And we wouldn’t expect any significant delays because the evidence has all been gathered already.

Janet: 22:12  Ukraine, I mean, it’s not as if we have an awful lot of Russians floating back through London anymore like they used to be. Is it likely that we’ll see some Ukraine prosecutions, maybe foreign fighters or? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 22:25  It doesn’t seem a high likelihood because we are the other side of Europe in the United Kingdom from Ukraine. And so not a lot again to end up here, unlike other countries closer to the conflict where you’re much more likely to end up with people amongst the refugee population may slip through. But it doesn’t seem a high likelihood of that. But also, I think what’s happening in that one is more that the UK authorities are supporting the International Criminal Court in their investigations. And so there’s a lot of mutual legal assistance speaking to witnesses. I think there are witnesses in Britain. And so the police are able to do investigations on behalf of the ICC or facilitate investigations. 

Janet: 23:01  Sudan, you mentioned and that’s, there is a very big Sudanese population in the UK. It’s an important relationship long term. So would we potentially see any cases here related to Sudan?

Rupert Skilbeck: 23:14  That one there could be, because you say there’s a diaspora population here. And certainly there have been attempts that are partially public to persuade the police to prosecute a couple of people relating to matters relating to Sudan. Not any of them have yet got fruition. But there’s been some attempts at that. Perhaps it’s early days yet. But in any situation where you have significant flows of refugees, it’s likely that people slip through. We had it after the Second World War. That’s why you ended up with people being prosecuted for Second World War crimes in this country. There were 2,000 people in this country who were suspected to be involved in Nazi atrocities. As it happens, only one was prosecuted. And some academics have recently done a study on why so few were prosecuted when there were so many suspects. 

Janet: 23:55  Because they were so useful, the rest of them, maybe, than the US. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 23:58  There’s a bit of that going on. And there’s a certain cultural thing that we’re not really interested in doing international trials in this country. The same reason that-

Janet: 24:08  What do you mean? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 24:09  Why is it that you’ve got thousands of trials going on elsewhere in Europe but so few in this country? There are issues, I think, relating to the fact that it’s a common law system. There is a political inertia when it comes to accountability in this country. So, for example, there have been virtually no prosecutions from Northern Ireland, despite the fact that there have been constant attempts by the European Court of Human Rights to challenge the impunity of the atrocities that took place and hadn’t been properly prosecuted. You had two and a half thousand reported incidents arising from the Iraq conflict. Those were all deemed to have been worthless in a very short period of time with one guilty plea. No prosecutions going forward. And then similarly, we have a much smaller number of international crimes prosecutions. So I think there is a certain political inertia that doesn’t favour prosecutions on an international basis. There may be an element of that that’s to do with Britain as a previous colonial power, because even, for example, some of the civil cases that have taken place, such as the attempt to prosecute or to hold the British colonial government responsible for atrocities against the Mau Mau in the 50s and 60s. 

Janet: 25:15  In Kenya. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 25:15  Yeah. And that one, again, Redress was to some extent involved in that. The case was taken forward by Lee Danko. And essentially, it ended up being settled. But again, huge inertia about British responsibility for what took place. Burning of documents and things. I’m going to challenge this use of the word inertia.

Janet: 25:31  I’m going to challenge this use of the word inertia. I can understand why, you know, you want to position yourself as political inertia. You’re talking about obstruction in some cases, not inertia and not actually having signed up to various documents, to various treaties, et cetera, not abiding by what they’ve signed up to. Well, I think this is more than inertia.

Rupert Skilbeck: 25:54  Well, I think the only public version of it is inertia, because when you actually dig into it, can you find anyone who said, stop, no, you can’t. 

Janet: 26:02  So do you think that it’s kind of within a meeting of the great and good who kind of say, oh, let’s not do this, chaps? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 26:09  Well, I mean, this is the question. How do these things happen? And I think this is what these academics who looked into the Second World War trials were trying to dig in to say, well, how did this happen?

Janet: 26:17  It was there at the meetings and who generally agreed these things. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 26:21  Yeah. And I think the problem is it’s very difficult to actually find someone who at a meeting said, we will not do this. But what you find is blocks are put up. Money is not allocated. People are moved to other jobs. 

Janet: 26:33  It’s a very yes minister, isn’t it? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 26:35  You can imagine the advice given that the minister said, well, I’m thinking that we should prosecute these 10 people responsible for war crime, well, that would be a very brave minister were you to do that. So it’s very difficult to dig into how this takes place. That’s why it’s a cultural question. And there’s a bit of that do as we say, not as we do. And I think that has a colonial background to it. And if you can track the history, it’s more of a job for an academic to do to track the history of the policy, that where did this history of lack of energy in prosecutions come from? And I think it came from the post-colonial period where the United Kingdom did not want to be held responsible for all sorts of things that took place. 

Janet: 27:12  And you’ve actually engaged with the police unit who work on these things. These are usually, in my experience, from the Dutch side, these are people who would like to see prosecutions go ahead. They believe in what they’re doing. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 27:25  Absolutely. 

Janet: 27:26  So they must feel quite undermined by the political, quote unquote, inertia. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 27:32  Yes, I mean, I think there has been a change in the last few years, because I think, and certainly since, probably for the last 15 years, there has been a change. I think that solid inertia was a 20th century thing. I think it has more recently changed. And certainly you’re absolutely right. The police within SO15 are doing this incredibly professional and dedicated investigators who know what they’re doing and have a clear purpose to make sure there’s no safe haven in the United Kingdom. And same with the prosecution lawyers who are dealing with it. So I mean, they’re very much committed to do it. One has to ask why in a bigger question, for example, there does seem to be this longer term history of failures of prosecution in the more complex and the more political arenas, such as Northern Ireland, such as Iraq. And those, I think, is where politics plays a greater part, because there are public enquiries that never quite come to fruition. There are recommendations that are never taken up. There are decisions that are never looked at again. But certainly on the actual cases that are being taken for by SO15 with allegations against people who are in this country, they’re doing those in a pretty aggressive way. 

Janet: 28:36  Just as I came in, you were mentioning one case that was happening today at the, was it at the High Court of Syria?

Rupert Skilbeck: 28:43  At the Old Bailey, so the Central Criminal Court. So yes, a man called Salem al-Salem has been charged with, was charged with murder as a crime against humanity in Syria. The man sadly has a very serious disease, which leads him completely incapacitated and I understand unable to communicate. And so that means, because he can’t communicate to his legal team, he can’t adequately defend himself. And so at an earlier hearing, I think earlier this year, the court found that he was not fit to plead. And so he cannot be held criminally responsible for what happened. But what is happening today is a hearing on whether or not they can move forward with a trial on the facts. And that’s a curious feature of English law. I think you have it in other common law systems where because he can’t be held criminally responsible because he hasn’t got the ability to defend himself properly or and hasn’t got mens rea that can be decided, the court makes a decision on whether the facts took place. 

Janet: 29:36  How can that, what good is that? Why does one do that? What for-

Rupert Skilbeck: 29:39  Well, it brings some, in a normal case, not an international crimes case, it’ll bring some closure for victims. So say it was a murder case and say a man was accused of murder, but he’s unfit to plead guilty for or plead guilty or not guilty, or unfit to be tried is the correct question, for whatever reason. They still need to know did this murder take place? Did that person kill that? And that’s helpful for the police to know that no one else did it, and for the victims to have some form of closure that this person committed that act, even if the court cannot say what the state of mind was in that person, whether they did it with intent or otherwise, and whether they’re guilty of murder or manslaughter. And so it gives you some conclusion as to what took place, and often you need it for technical reasons, like you need to know why someone died so that wills can be proved and insurance policies can be used. So there’s often practical reasons for it. It’s never happened for an international crime before. 

Janet: 30:29  So this is a first.

Rupert Skilbeck: 30:30  Yeah, as far as I’m aware. So that’s super interesting, because what you actually then have is potentially, to be decided, a trial of the facts as to whether or not the base crimes or crimes against- murderers- or crimes against humanity, a widespread and systematic attack against the civilian population, took place in Syria. And that would mean the prostitution proving that, beyond a reasonable doubt, it’s a criminal standard in a British court that that took place, while saying that the defendant participated in that and did these things, without saying they are criminally responsible. Now that has big implications, because that’s a significant enterprise. That, that would, we’ll see how they would seek to prove it. Maybe it would be expert witnesses. Maybe it would be by talking about other criminal judgments that have taken place, calling some factual witnesses. It might not be disputed by the defence. One would have to see what the defence position is. Do they dispute that crimes against humanity have taken place? Maybe they accept it. But that hasn’t taken place before. So that’d be super interesting. And of course, one then has to wonder whether that could happen in another context, such as determinations that genocide have taken place. And so that, currently, the British government’s position is that British courts are not in a position to determine whether genocide has taken place. 

Janet: 31:41  Because? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 31:42  Because unless it’s an actual trial. So the ICJ can do it. And someone can be convicted in another court of a criminal offence of genocide. But they’re not prepared to determine whether, in the non-criminal context, genocide has taken place. They say that’s for courts to decide, not this one. 

Janet: 32:00  Why is that inconsistency? 

Rupert Skilbeck: 32:02  Well, I think no one has ever called them on it before. And so if one has to ask, if the Old Bailey is potentially, subject to the decisions being made, able to determine that a crime against humanity has taken place, why can’t they determine that genocide has taken place?

Janet: 32:17  Beyond these things that we’ve spoken about, I was also wondering about other kinds of potential ways of bringing people to courts, which would be things like corporate responsibility, issues to do with supply chains, slavery, and so on. I mean, that’s a big thing always in UK government, isn’t it? Sort of an anti-slavery policy. Are we seeing any kinds of prosecutions to do in the UK? I’m walking around London. It’s a huge number of businesses here. It’s a big economy here. Is there, are there prospects of corporate accountability cases?

Rupert Skilbeck: 32:54  I mean, I think for modern slavery and trafficking, it’s much more likely to be direct responsibility in people who are involved in in facilitating trafficking and employing people who’ve been trafficked and doing it knowingly.

Janet: 33:06  Yeah, I mean, that’s definitely sort of the Libya and then Eritrea and then small boats, which is a big political issue in the UK. That’s definitely something that’s happening, isn’t it?

Rupert Skilbeck: 33:16  Yeah, I mean, so there’s a lot of focus on prosecution of trafficking cases, but they’re done as trafficking. The issue with the corporate liability here is a lack of clarity in extended forms of responsibility for international crimes. And so, for example, the International Criminal Court hasn’t really considered corporate liability. We know that there are cases against London and things in Sweden and France, but they’re often against the directors personally liable. And that’s how you’d have to do it here as well. You’d struggle very much to have any corporate liability because it would be personal liability for the directors of the company. That means you’ve got to prove that they knew what was going on. And there’s a bit of a mess. Again, it came up in our report. The definition of secondary forms of responsibility is not entirely clear because under the International Criminal Court, you have command responsibility. Under English law, you have to have aiding and abetting. And that’s a little bit different to how aiding and abetting is defined in international criminal law by the International Criminal Court and the tribunals and the rest of it. Then you have forms of group responsibility. You used to have joint criminal enterprise in English law, but it got pushed aside recently because of a case called Jogi that essentially had a very different way of you interpret responsibility, mens rea, and other issues relating to group liability, whereas in the International Criminal Court has moved to things such as indirect-

Janet: 34:32  Motive liability with direct and indirect-

Rupert Skilbeck: 34:34  Indirect co-perpetration. That doesn’t exist in English law. 

Janet: 34:37  No. Yeah.

Rupert Skilbeck: 34:8  It’s a German concept. And so what you have is you can’t really directly apply ICC and ICTY-STL jurisprudence to English law. It doesn’t work. And then the police have had some concerns on directly applying conspiracy to commit these crimes, incitement to commit these crimes, encouraging. And then there are new offences under the Serious Crime Act 2005 that have never been tried-

Janet: 35:00  Which are?

Rupert Skilbeck: 35:01  Which are things like encouraging and I think planning offences, but they’ve never been applied to these crimes. And so you you’ve got a rather difficult situation where those forms of liability are untested when you apply them to crimes against humanity and the chapeau element of crimes against humanity and all the different complex elements there as well. And so if you are to apply all of that messy area of law to corporate responsibility, that’s not a straightforward process. And particularly if you’re going to take forward an international crimes investigation and prosecution, it’s going to take many years. It’s going to cost an awful lot of money and involve an awful lot of lawyers. And so where you have a slightly uncertain legal environment, that doesn’t build confidence for people to take forward cases. And so one thing we’ve suggested is people look at that law a little bit more and see if it needs to be clarified in some way.

Janet: 35:53  So big picture, do you think that the UK is on its way now finally to being one of the places where we’re going to see more international crimes be prosecuted? Or do you think it’s going to dribble along as it has up until now?

Rupert Skilbeck: 36:07  I mean, I think there are some possibilities for that. I don’t think we’ll have the large numbers that took place in Germany, for example, just due to the-

Janet: 36:15  Why not?

Rupert Skilbeck: 36:16  Well, I mean, you’ve got to think that there were such large numbers of refugees moved into Germany, possibly with not much in the way of vetting. The process to get to the United Kingdom is more complicated and you don’t, you just don’t get quite so many numbers. But there are big movements that are taking place. One of the big movements recently is people coming from Bangladesh from the former regime who are trying to set up home in the United Kingdom. And we also know that many former regime senior folk own huge amounts of property.

Janet: 36:48  That’s, again, a British political issue, isn’t it?

Rupert Skilbeck: 36:50  Absolutely. I mean, there’s one former minister of Bangladesh who owns 700 properties in London. And we know that Rifaat al-Assad owned a big house in London, so.

Janet: 36:58  That was the Syrian uncle of the actual previous leader.

Rupert Skilbeck: 37:04  Exactly. So there have always been these connections. And I think they will continue to do so. But I think perhaps there haven’t been the quantity of numbers that mean that significant perpetrators have come here. But what we do have, there’s a thing called the Article 1F unit in Liverpool, within the Home Office.

Janet: 37:19  What’s that? What is Article 1F?

Rupert Skilbeck: 37:21  Article 1F is Article 1F of the Refugee Convention, which means that if you claim refugee status, you may be denied refugee status if you have, I can’t remember the exact test, but it’s something like participated in international crimes. A curious number of people in their interview to claim asylum say, well, I was involved in fighting for the rebels, which is why I had to leave the country because I’m under threat from the government. But if those rebels committed international crimes, then you’re potentially admitting something. And Agnes Taylor, the wife of Charles Taylor, was tried at the Old Bailey, but ultimately the trial didn’t go forward for various reasons.

Janet: 37:53  Yeah, the Liberian former leader who was tried at the Sierra Leone Special Court.

Rupert Skilbeck: 37:58  Exactly. 

Janet: 37:59  So one of his wives. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 38:00  For Crimes Against Humanity. 

Janet: 38:01 Yeah.

Rupert Skilbeck: 38:01  And his wife was in the United Kingdom and had accepted in her assignment that she had acted for one of the rebel groups and was a leader of the rebel group. And so then the prostitution looked, and the police looked at it and realised that, well, that group committed war crimes and she could potentially be liable. Now that trial collapsed for various other reasons due to the timing requirements of Crimes Against Humanity. Crimes Against Humanity can only be prosecuted from 1991 going forward.

Janet: 38:28  Because of when the act came in.

Rupert Skilbeck: 38:30  That’s where the cutoff time has been defined by the ICC Act under English law. These offences took place something like six months earlier than that. So she had to be tried for torture. And the problem with torture is torture has to be conducted by a state authority of the criminal justice authority. A public authority has to have committed the offence. And she was in charge of a rebel group. And so the central court-

Janet: 38:52 So she fell between the cracks.

Rupert Skilbeck: 38:53  Absolutely, decided that as there was no evidence before the court that her rebel group had a quasi-statal authority, possibly that evidence would have been available, the prosecution wasn’t taking forward and the case was terminated on that basis. But that unit does hear lots of cases of people who are accepting that they were fighting for rebel groups, which may well have committed atrocities. And so I think quite a few will come through from perhaps Sudan, perhaps from Bangladesh, perhaps from other places.

Janet: 39:20  It still feels very much though, what you’re talking about there is the UK not being a safe haven, essentially. But there’s still that sense of, oh, when are we ever going to get the UK politically to stand behind what it has signed up to in terms of genocide convention, torture convention, ICC, this, that and the other. Should be a much more major player, should it not?

Rupert Skilbeck: 39:47  I mean, certainly, for example, we were trying to persuade the British government to put in place a few very modest reforms that would make it easier to prosecute people. Say, for example, if you commit genocide and you come to the United Kingdom, you can’t be prosecuted unless you’re resident in the United Kingdom. Well, that’s hopeless. Why on earth can’t you prosecute these people who are passing through? That’s our obligation under international law. Curiously, for torture, if you’re a visitor, you can be prosecuted, but not for crimes against humanity or genocide. So that’s a crazy situation. We were encouraging the British government to make a very modest change to to make that. 

Janet: 40:19  Just with reference to genocide at least. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 40:15  Absolutely, genocide and crimes against humanity. And they wouldn’t do it. And the view is, oh, it’s not important. We don’t need to do that. The system works.

Janet: 40:29  But we can see how important it is because we the, we have people from countries that may be committing genocide, whether it’s Sudan, whether it’s Israel, whether it’s somewhere else. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 40:39  No, and I’m afraid it’s very clear double standards from the politicians in the British government who will go around the world telling everyone else they must prosecute people for crimes against humanity and genocide, but won’t make a simple change to make it easier to prosecute it in this country. And it goes down to the fact that this is, unfortunately, a not high question of politics. It’s not a top priority for anyone in the British government. And either it’s not getting considered properly by ministers, or the ministers are thinking we don’t need to make this change. But it is, it is double standards. There’s no two ways about it. And people across the world see that. It’s not just Britain. Many other countries do it as well. I mean, many countries in Europe haven’t properly domesticated their own statute, yet will tell countries in Africa they must do it. So we need to make sure that European countries, in particular, are doing what they say and not doing things differently. And that really has an impact. I think there is a broader question with international justice in that the vast majority of people, unfortunately, do get away with it. Because as we know, the International Criminal Court can only prosecute a handful of people. And realistically, even though there are several thousand prosecutions going on across Europe and elsewhere, it’s still only the tip of the iceberg. But that is the way international justice works, that we do try and year on year have more people prosecuted, so that we can see that the long arc of justice is moving in favour of accountability, to make sure we’re not moving into an age of impunity, which is, at the moment, I think we’re at a tipping point as to which way we’re going. And so, yes, there are some prosecutions going on in the United Kingdom, yes, more could take place. And there are some really easy reforms that could be made to make it easier to prosecute people in this country. The same narrative applies, I think, globally, that we have to work out exactly what needs to be done in each of the different places to make accountability more likely.

Janet: 42:25  As I wrap up, the first general question we always ask is, is there something that I should have asked you that I didn’t ask you?

Rupert Skilbeck: 42:32  What we didn’t cover is special mission immunity.

Janet: 42:34  What is special mission immunity, Rupert?

Rupert Skilbeck: 42:36  So this curiously exists in many countries, either in a quiet, private way or in a formal way. And it’s essentially a get-out-of-jail-free card. And so its, the British government has it now in a formal way, possibly following things that were addressed several years ago, where it was a more informal way of doing it. So this is a way when someone is coming to the United Kingdom who may have been involved in international crimes and they don’t-

Janet: 43:01  So like a senior minister or-

Rupert Skilbeck: 43:03  Well, let’s say an Egyptian general. And so a few years ago, General Hegazi came to the United Kingdom and there were firm allegations that he had been involved in international crime, things that would amount to international crime. Well, it was torture, in fact, rather than international crimes. And so an Egyptian opposition party attempted to challenge the fact that he was granted special mission immunity and Redress intervened in that case to say that you shouldn’t be granting SMI in cases involving torture when there’s an absolute obligation to prosecute.

Janet: 43:31  And the special mission immunity is the idea of that is they’re here to, let’s say, I don’t know, negotiate a peace or something like that.

Rupert Skilbeck: 43:39  Yes, well, in this one, he was here to attend an arms-

Janet: 43:42  Well, that’s illegitimate, isn’t it? That’s very important to carry on, to be able to sell some arms to Egypt. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 43:47  Ultimately, that was the position of the British government was that they have an obligation to support the arms industry in this country, and therefore people need to come and buy those weapons. And if those people may have committed torture, well, let’s give them a get out of jail free card. So that particular case, we lost that. And the House of Lords, I think it’s the Supreme Court by then, decided that no special mission immunity did exist in international law, despite some rather weak underpinnings. And if that was a form of immunity for international crimes, now that isn’t accepted in lots of other places. And so that’s an area that needs to be challenged.

Janet: 44:18  It’s really kind of deterrence to the executive, isn’t it? It’s saying you decide, Minister, who you want to let in.

Rupert Skilbeck: 44:25  Well, what has happened recently is that the government hasn’t been using it. And so what we did succeed in doing is that the process for special immunity became more formal and more structured. And then various members of parliament would ask questions, asking how many times it had been used in the last year. And so the figures that that extra shining a light on it was very helpful. And so what happened certainly is the current government has essentially committed not to use special mission immunity at all. And I think they haven’t granted SMI immunity certificates the last two years. And so what that does mean is that we would then know about it, who has been granted why, and questions can be asked as to why that may take place. It does exist in other countries. In Germany, they have a similar system that allows for example, if there are diplomats visiting in, for example, Sudan, it might be a peace conference on Sudan. And then you have to see that there may be- 

Janet: 45:12  There’s a balance-

Rupert Skilbeck: 45:13  There is a balance. And we would have a position on that. But we can perhaps understand why the British government might come to a different view. But this is a problem globally. It’s not just in this country. We managed to shine a light on it in this country, but it is elsewhere as well. But it can be very badly used. And it’s very easy to give very villainous people the ability to come to this country and give them immunity in whatever way. But of course, there is no immunity for international crimes and for torture. 

Janet: 45:37  Full stop. 

Rupert Skilbeck: 45:38  And so, exactly. And we know that the House of Lords held that in the Pinochet case. And so we have good examples in British law where we have challenged impunity and immunities for torture, and less useful examples such the General Hegazy case, where we didn’t win.

Janet: 45:53  And the last question that we always ask is, is there something you’ve been reading recently, watching, listening to, that you’d like to recommend to people? Here we are in the Redress offices, and you’ve been shoving various reports at me. So you can always recommend one of your reports as kind of the most interesting. Have to have it next to your bedside, reading Redress report on what’s that Global Britain, Global Justice, or maybe something a bit more interesting.

Rupert Skilbeck: 46:18  Well, it’s certainly if you want to know about how international criminal law works in English law, that report, Global Britain, Global Justice, sets it all out very succinctly. I don’t recommend…

Janet: 46:28  I’ll put a link into that. But what do you actually read?

Rupert Skilbeck: 46:30  I don’t recommend reading any of this stuff at the weekend or at night. You have to take time off. It’s good to keep these things based in the office. But every now and then, I try to think, I wish you’d warn me of this one. What is interesting is when journalists write about the cases that we do, because I think human rights lawyers, whether it’s doing international criminal cases, or you’re doing, whether UJ cases, or they’re human rights cases, we often have to tell the story in a quite legal way. But every now and then, journalists get involved and tell the story. And so there’s a few cases where some of the cases we worked on have been written up by journalists. So that there’s a very great case from years ago called People’s History of the European Court of Human Rights that tells the story of… Many of them are torture cases of people that were tortured by various authorities and tells the stories in a really interesting way that humanises the victim and how they ended up seeking justice. And I think those ones, that are often written by journalists, telling the stories of the people we work for, are often the most interesting.

Janet: 47:28  Thank you very much for spending a bit of Friday afternoon with me as we got in the news about the ICC being sanctioned. We’re both going to check our phones, I think. But thank you very much.

Rupert Skilbeck: 47:38  Thanks for the good questions.

[OUTRO MUSIC]

Narrator: 47:45  That’s it for this episode of Asymmetrical Haircuts, the international justice podcast created and presented by Janet Anderson and Stephanie van den Berg in partnership with the Hague Humanity Hub. This episode was also produced with justiceinfo.net, an independent site covering justice efforts for mass violence. If you want show notes, past episodes or just to dig deeper into what we’ve covered today, head to asymmetricalhaircuts.com. And if you enjoyed this one, subscribe wherever you listen, leave us a rating and tell a friend.

Stay safe and enjoy your day.

Disclaimer: This transcript was generated using online transcribing software, and checked and supplemented by the Asymmetrical Haircuts team. Because of this we cannot guarantee it is completely error free. Please check the corresponding audio for any errors before quoting.